
South Africa’s 4 November local government elections left no party in control of Johannesburg, Tshwane or Ekurhuleni. Nationally, the ANC took 30.75% of the vote, the DA 24.65% and the MK Party 9.77%. In Gauteng, the DA won 33.96%, the ANC 21.54% and ActionSA 16.87%.
Those figures have made ActionSA a kingmaker. Reports say the black-led parties (the ANC, MK, EFF, IFP and PA) want ActionSA to join a coalition, or that ActionSA is courting them. ActionSA’s leader, Herman Mashaba, has set a condition for working with the DA in Johannesburg: Helen Zille must not be its mayoral candidate. On 8 November, eNCA reported that he would work with the DA in Johannesburg, but not with Zille. He later offered to withdraw his own mayoral bid if Zille also stepped aside. DA leader Geordin Hill-Lewis called the demand “difficult to swallow” but would not set red lines.
Mashaba has said his objection is to Zille and Cilliers Brink, not to the DA as a whole. On 17 November he told Newzroom Afrika that “there is no way” ActionSA would hand the black vote to them. In 2025, when Zille’s candidacy was announced, he questioned the DA’s lack of black leaders, saying the party could not find “a single black person in this province” to run the city.
His own record makes the condition harder to explain. Mashaba has spent years insisting he would never work with the ANC. In 2022, after a survey of supporters, ActionSA refused coalition talks with the party. In 2024, days after standing with the ANC to oust the DA’s mayor in Tshwane, Mashaba accused the DA of jeopardising the coalition. ActionSA’s Tshwane coalition also includes the EFF, a party he had previously called thugs. He justified the ANC deal by saying he had had enough of being abused by racists using his vote. In 2026 he defended the same willingness to work with the ANC, despite earlier vowing never to enter into a coalition with it.
The Zille condition is about one person, which makes it harder to square with Tshwane.
Zille’s record also needs weighing. She was Mayor of Cape Town from 2006 to 2009 and was named the 2008 World Mayor by City Mayors, an international urban-affairs think tank. She has said the DA doubled the average annual rate of housing delivery, from around 3,000 homes a year under the ANC between 2002 and 2006 to around 7,000 a year between 2006 and 2008. Her critics point to poor service delivery in housing, electricity and sanitation, the open toilet saga in Makhaza, and stadium costs. Analysts have said her record is often held up as a model of efficient governance, but that the picture is less clear once the branding is set aside.
On 18 November, Mashaba posted on X: “Black Unity is a threat to cowards like these.” The post came in the same week coalition talks were under way in Gauteng.
Mashaba has spent years insisting he would never work with the ANC, and in Tshwane he did. Now he says he will work with the DA, but not with Helen Zille. Whether that is principle or positioning will be measured less by his speeches than by what his voters do when the coalition deals are finalised.